Rob would get bored quickly of the V8 S4 unless its been well played with.
Lets face it you would always want the RS4
Both are only good for very low double figure MPG when driven

I have just got a new job and i get a company car,which is good but i really wanted a budget so i could get an RS4 by adding my own dosh

Now got to decide do i take the Audi A5 or the 3 series bmw